Hold, witness and review points
A hold point means work may not continue until the named party has inspected and released it. A witness point means the party is notified and may attend, but work can proceed if they do not. A review point is a check of records. Your inspection and test plan (ITP) names who holds each point: contractor QA/QC, the owner’s inspector or both.
| Point | Type | What is checked |
|---|---|---|
| Before first production weld | Hold | Qualification on file, correct WPS or weld schedule, equipment calibration, purge set-up |
| First welds on each machine setup | Hold | Visual and borescope examination of sample or first welds |
| Start of each shift | Witness or review | Sample weld if the owner specification requires one |
| Before a joint becomes inaccessible | Hold | Examination of welds that will be closed in, insulated or built over |
| Material change or new size range | Hold | Qualification range and procedure match |
| Before pressure or leak test | Hold | Weld log complete for the boundary, all welds examined |
Setting them up
- Start from the owner’s ITP or inspection requirements and your quality plan.
- Add the new-crew points above for an agreed period or number of welds.
- Agree notice times with the owner’s inspector so hold points do not stall the crew.
- Brief the foreman and crew on what stops work and who releases it.
- Record each release with name, date and weld numbers.
Relaxing them
Decide the release criteria up front, for example a number of consecutive acceptable welds per welder and setup, as agreed with your QA manager and the owner. Base the decision on the crew’s actual records (reject rate tracking), not on time elapsed. Code-required and owner-required points stay regardless.
Making hold points work on site
Hold points fail when nobody knows they exist or nobody comes to release them. Put the hold points on the work package or traveller the crew uses, so the welder sees them at the joint. Give the foreman the names and contact details of the people who can release each point, and agree what happens out of hours. If the owner’s inspector cannot attend within the agreed notice, record the request and the delay; that record protects the crew and the schedule.
Where the owner and code decide
ASME B31.3 sets required examinations and the owner’s inspector’s right to inspect; the owner specification and ITP set the hold points that are mandatory. Your additional new-crew points are your own control and can be adjusted, but tell the owner if you change them, since they may rely on them.