Site leadership and quality · Nonconformance

Handling a nonconformance report raised against a new crew

Treat the NCR as a process, not a verdict on the crew: contain the affected work, find the cause, agree the disposition with whoever has authority, fix it, and close the report with evidence. An NCR in the first weeks often points to an onboarding gap, such as a site rule nobody explained, rather than a skill problem.

Steps from report to closure

  1. Contain. Identify every weld or spool that could be affected (same welder, same setup, same material, same period) and stop further work of that kind until the cause is known.
  2. Describe the facts. What was found, where, against which requirement, with photos and weld numbers.
  3. Find the cause. Equipment, procedure, material, instruction or person. Talk to the crew with an interpreter if needed.
  4. Agree the disposition. Repair, replace, use as is or reject, decided by the person or body the quality plan names; some dispositions need the owner’s agreement.
  5. Correct and prevent. Fix the work, then change whatever allowed it, such as a briefing, a hold point or a setup check.
  6. Close with evidence. Re-examination records, revised briefings and the sign-offs your quality plan requires.

Common causes with new crews

NCR causes often seen in a crew’s first weeks (check yours, do not assume)
CauseExampleTypical correction
Site rule not briefedWeld marking format or bagging rule different from the crew’s last siteBrief the rule, add it to the induction
Equipment differencesDifferent orbital power supply or head from what the crew used beforeSupervised setup, sample welds
Document revisionWork done to a superseded isometricDocument control check at the workface
LanguageInstruction misunderstoodWritten instruction in both languages, confirm back
Individual skillOne welder’s repeated rejectsSee the retrain, retest or replace decision

If the cause is one person’s skill, the employment decision is covered in when a new welder keeps failing.

Where the owner spec and quality plan decide

Who may raise an NCR, who decides the disposition and whether the owner must approve “use as is” or repair are set by your quality plan and the owner specification. Code requirements, such as re-examination after repair, also apply. Do not close an NCR on a verbal agreement.

Keeping the NCR register useful

Keep one register for the project, with the NCR number, date raised, affected weld or spool numbers, cause category, disposition, who approved it and the closure date. Review it weekly with the foreman and site manager. Repeated causes in the register show where the onboarding or the procedures need changing; the register is also one of the first things an owner auditor asks for (owner QA audit records).

Talking to the crew

A new crew may read an NCR as a threat to their jobs. Explain the process, separate the cause from blame and show the corrective action. If the crew includes a Korean-speaking foreman, involve them in the explanation (mixed-language crews).

Frequently asked questions

Should one NCR cover several welds?

If they share one cause, one NCR with a list of affected welds is usually clearer. Your quality plan may set the rule.

Can the contractor decide “use as is” alone?

Usually not where the work does not meet the owner’s requirement. That disposition normally needs the owner’s or engineer’s approval.

How fast should an NCR be closed?

There is no universal deadline. Contain immediately; closure depends on the repair and re-examination. Owners often track open NCR age, so do not let them sit.

Have a fab scope that needs these trades?

Requests are in preview: you can fill in the request form, but it does not submit yet. Email WELDK with your roles, site country and start window.