Split the scope by line type
| Scope item | Usual trade | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Bulk and specialty gas distribution, 316L EP/BA tube | Orbital welder | Repeatable autogenous welds, low heat input, inside-surface finish matters, owner specs usually require machine welding and weld logs |
| Gas cabinet, VMB/VMP and tool hook-up tube | Orbital welder | Same tube class; tight spaces need compact heads and careful setup |
| Vacuum and exhaust lines in stainless | Orbital or manual TIG | Depends on diameter, wall and specification; larger ducts are often manual |
| Process cooling water, utility and carbon steel pipe | Manual TIG (often with other processes for fill and cap) | Larger diameters and thicker walls, all-position hand welding |
| Battery plant solvent, slurry and utility stainless pipe | Manual TIG | Larger pipe is often welded by hand (orbital pipe heads exist but are less common on these scopes); root quality and back-purge matter |
| Tie-ins, repairs and field adjustments | Manual TIG | Limited clearance, irregular fit-up, no time for head setup |
| Plastic chemical and UPW lines (PVDF, PFA, PP) | Neither | Joined by plastic fusion or flare and mechanical fittings, by a different trade |
Why the two are separate hires
An orbital welder’s skill is mostly in preparation and control: squaring and facing tube ends, choosing and grinding tungsten, setting the head, developing or following a weld schedule, controlling purge and reading coupons. A manual TIG welder’s skill is in the hands: torch angle, filler feed and travel in every position. Someone excellent at one is not automatically competent at the other, which is why codes qualify them differently (see welder or welding operator).
Questions that settle the ratio
- How many tube welds versus pipe welds are in the work packages, and in which sizes?
- Does the owner specification require orbital welding for all high-purity tube, or only above a certain size?
- Which orbital equipment brand and head models will the site use? Experience on the same equipment shortens setup time.
- Will the crew prefabricate spools in a shop area, or weld mostly in place? In-place work needs more manual capacity.
- Who develops weld schedules — your QA team, the equipment supplier or the lead orbital welder?
When one person can cover both
Some technicians have done both kinds of work. Treat that as two separate claims: ask for the tube sizes and equipment they used, the pipe sizes and positions they welded, and test each one you plan to use them for. On a WELDK profile, each claim is marked as candidate-provided, reviewed by staff or employer-tested (how to read a profile).