Questions and what to listen for
| Question | Good answers include | Warning signs |
|---|---|---|
| Which specification and acceptance criteria did you inspect to last? | Names the owner spec or standard and describes its main criteria | “The usual standard” |
| How did you link each weld to its welder, material and date? | Weld numbering, heat number records, log updated daily | Records filled in at the end of the job |
| What do you check before a welder makes the first production weld of the shift? | Qualification status, WPS or schedule, sample weld if the spec requires it | Nothing until the weld is finished |
| Tell me about an NCR you raised. How was it closed? | Clear description, disposition agreed, evidence of closure | Never raised one, or closed by verbal agreement |
| What goes into a test package you handed over? | Isometrics, weld log, examination records, test records, punch list | Unclear on contents |
| When would you call the owner’s inspector instead of deciding yourself? | Hold points, disputed acceptance, deviations from the spec | Never, or for everything |
Practical exercises
- Show six to ten photos of outside weld surfaces and borescope images of the inside, including acceptable and rejectable ones from your own site if you have them.
- Give the candidate the relevant acceptance criteria from the owner specification, often based on SEMI F81 for GTA welds.
- Ask them to accept or reject each one, state the reason and say what they would record.
- Then give a small isometric with weld numbers and a matching log with a few deliberate errors, and ask them to find the errors.
The exercise works by video for a candidate still in Korea, if you share the images and documents in advance or on screen.
Where your QA manager and the owner decide
Your QA manager sets the pass level for the exercises, decides whether a certification is required (inspector certification) and approves who may sign records. The owner specification sets the acceptance criteria. Do not let the candidate’s preferred standard replace the one your project uses.
Score the image exercise in two parts: whether the accept or reject decision matched your reference, and whether the reason and record were clear enough for an auditor. A candidate who reaches the right decision but cannot explain it will struggle when the owner questions a record. A candidate who is cautious and rejects a borderline weld, with a clear reason, is usually less risk than one who accepts it to keep work moving.
Questions for fab-specific judgement
- What does heavy inside discoloration tell you about the purge, and who do you tell?
- How do you store borescope images so they can be found for a specific weld later?
- What do you do if a welder’s qualification is near its continuity limit?