What changes by material
| Material | Typical use on site | What separates good welders | What to test |
|---|---|---|---|
| Austenitic stainless (304L, 316L) | Process cooling, exhaust, chemical and solvent lines | Back-purge set-up, low heat tint, clean root without sugaring | Root on your smallest stainless pipe in a fixed position |
| Carbon steel | Utilities, fire protection, structural attachments | Root penetration and tie-ins, fit-up on larger diameters | Root and hot pass to your WPS; fill and cap if they will do it |
| Duplex stainless | Some aggressive-service lines | Heat input and interpass control, purge, filler choice per WPS | Only if your scope has it; follow the WPS limits closely |
| Dissimilar joints | Stainless to carbon steel at interfaces | Filler selection per WPS, controlled dilution | Only where the scope includes them |
Positions and diameters matter as much as material
A welder who has welded 316L pipe on the bench may struggle with the same pipe fixed overhead between a rack and a ceiling. Ask for positions and diameter ranges welded in the last projects, and match your test to the worst realistic case. Qualification ranges for positions and diameters are set by the code and your WPS (see how qualification works).
Questions to ask
- Which materials did you weld on your last two projects, and in which sizes and positions?
- How did you set up the back-purge on a long stainless spool?
- What did your WPS say about interpass temperature, and how did you check it?
- Did you weld only the root, or root to cap?
Where your QA team decides
Filler metals, heat input, interpass limits and acceptance criteria are set by your welding procedures and the code you build to. Use them as the reference for both the interview and the test, and give them to the candidate before the test.